'Scotland the Brave' - Carl reid

Discussion in 'Figure News' started by Grod, Apr 16, 2019.

  1. Andrew Belsey Well-Known Member

    Country:
    United-Kingdom
    My Waterloo Companion says that the 1st and 4th Cuirassiers we’re tasked to protect the flanks of d’Erlon’s infantry.
    Andy
    Grod and Constantin67 like this.
  2. Constantin67 Well-Known Member

    Country:
    Russian-Federation
    Thanks Andy(y)
    Grod likes this.
  3. Barrie Harris Active Member

    Country:
    United-Kingdom
    Another winner for you Gordon. Stunning work.

    Barrie(Newbee)
    Grod likes this.
  4. juno New Member

    Fantastic group and very impressive dramatic scene.

    @Constantin and Andy - according to the time relations of the French army the 2nd RNB Dragoons Scots Greys have been counter-charged by the IV Cavalry Reserve 14th Cavalry division 1st Brigade with Gal Farine du Creux 5th and 10th Cuirassiers, and further flanked-charged by 4th Chevaux-légers Lanciers with Colonel Bro
    Grod likes this.
  5. Constantin67 Well-Known Member

    Country:
    Russian-Federation
    Thank you, in the above picture of Stanley Berkeley, I see the red collars at the cuirassier. It is right ? I am doing this job now and it is important for me to paint correctly. What regimental colors were at the 5th cuirassier in 1815?
  6. Huw63 A Fixture

    Country:
    Switzerland
    Aurore - note 4th, 5th and 6th regiments all had aurore collars piped blue.

    Distinctions were in cuffs and cuff flaps, buttons and the plate on front of the comb of the helmet. If the gauntlet gloves were worn the cuffs and cuff flaps weren’t visible.

    Paul Dawson recently published an excellent book on the topic of Napoleon’s Waterloo army uniforms.

    Cheers

    Huw

    Addendum: just at lunch and checked facing colour chart. 5th had aurore cuffs and blue cuff flaps piped aurore.
    Constantin67 and Grod like this.
  7. juno New Member

    Hello again,
    Just for the sake...
    I would consider this painting for an artist view that might be different from the true events.

    To my knowledge none of the comments by British officers who were on the field would mention actions of cuirassiers regiments against the heavy Union division's charges against d'Erlon's corps.

    2nd RNB Dragoons' letters collected by Sitborne in the 1840's do mention French lancer's pursuit (and the death of Lord Ponsonby) but nothing about the French heavies.
    Quite the same from the Inniskillings who remembered seeing lancers attacking the left wing but do not speak about other French cavalry units.

    It then seems difficult to determine the true actions.
    Huw63 likes this.
  8. juno New Member

    If useful I can PM you a link with snapshot of a 5th's officer in a French small book about Cuirassiers uniforms
    I think this book also exists in English but it might be out-of-print
  9. fogie A Fixture

    Country:
    United-Kingdom
    Juno you're probably right...up to a point. Victorian artists, like several model sculptors today, seldom let historical
    details get in their way. The sculptor who bases his work on a painting can hide nicely behind the artist's mistakes - the
    one who buys the figure is left to correct whatever he feels is necessary - thoroughly irksome to some of us, but not much
    of an issue for others who see beyond what they think of as pedantry. I'm actually with you on this......so well said.

    Mike
    Huw63 likes this.
  10. juno New Member

    Thank you Mike, definitely agreed.
  11. Huw63 A Fixture

    Country:
    Switzerland
    Mike and Juno I fully agree with your views concerning the Victorian painting. My view are, to paraphrase the Duke Of Wellington, the history of a battle can be as futile as that of a history of a ball: the memoirs only relate to the personal experiences of the individual and they would have no idea what was going to a few feet away. I think that the notion of brave Scots infantry grabbing stirrups of the horses of their countrymen to be carried to fight the French is unlikely given the numbers of highlanders who were reported dead in square: had they done this charge they would have been slaughtered by the lancers. Moreover it's likely that anyone foolish enough to try it would lose their grip or fallen over pretty quickly. The recent dig around the location of the British field dressing station showed that heavy fighting took place in the vicinity, intense fighting not before reported despite hundreds of tomes on the subject.

    As to the dress I always love the Rousselot comment which basically says that if we today saw the Napoleonic army we'd certainly have a few surprises. Paul Dawson is producing some fine research which does contradict some commonly held "facts" about dress and some great discussions go on with other contemporary uniformologists such as Yves Martin . I think I ought to make it clear that correspond with them both and at the moment am nagging Paul to publish all his research about French heavy cavalry dress and equipment but I have no vested interest other than wanting to read the results of his research. Of course without being there we don't fully know.

    Enough of my waffle.

    Cheers,

    Huw
    fogie likes this.

Share This Page

planetFigure Links

Reviews & Open Box
Buy. Sell & trade
Articles
Link Directory
Events
Advertising

Popular Sections

Figure & Minis News
vBench - Works in Progress
Painting Talk
Sculpting Talk
Digital Sculpting Talk
The Lounge
Report Piracy

Who we are

planetFigure is a community built around miniature painters, sculptors and collectors, We are here to exchange support, Information & Resources.

© planetFigure 2003 - 2019.